
We paid for surplus last year
BY the time you read this you will probably have seen some press saying how Vincent has kept the annual rates rise down to 4 per cent.
This is probably reasonable given potential cost increases for Vincent including employee costs going up by just under 7 per cent!
It would be a good thing if this was due to sound financial management.
However, the reality is the exact opposite – the increase has been kept down because of poor financial management in the past, and the reality is that we paid for some of this last year.
When the Vincent financial boffins presented the 2023-24 budget to council last June they predicted that the city would start the 2023-24 financial year with a $4.1 million carried forward surplus.
Once the auditors had done their work it was discovered that the reality was that the actual surplus was over $9 million.
About $1.4 million of the increase was because the federal government made an unexpected grant prepayment.
Another $1.1 million was because the predicted amount to be carried over for capital was too low.
Why they didn’t realise that at budget time, in June, is a mystery.
Suffice it to say it wasn’t a problem for ratepayers as we didn’t need to pay more rates to cover it.
Which leaves $2.4 million that was collected from us this year, but would not have been needed if they had come within cooee of correctly predicting the actual carryover.
It was made up of underestimated parking and Beatty Park revenue for last year, and higher than predicted interest from investments.
I’m sorry for labouring the point, but these were predictions they dished up to the council on 20 June, 10 days before the start of the financial year. It would not be accepted in private enterprise.
But it’s more than just poor predictions.
Vincent’s director of community and business services left in October 2022.
Rather than advertise the position, the CEO took it upon himself to do the job as well as the job of CEO.
And, no he did not get paid extra for that.
The strange thing was that ratepayers had to fork out $343,790 for ‘employee costs’ related to the position as part of the budget – presumably that included the cost for the director and an executive assistant. Remember the position was effectively vacant.
When I asked for details about how much was actually spent up until 31 March I got an evasive answer that would have provided Blackadder with one of those “he was more evasive than a …” sort of response.
Strangely, and by sheer coincidence, after I started asking questions about it, the position was filled on an acting capacity.
The upshot is that ratepayers may have paid up to $250,000 this year for a position(s) that wasn’t needed.
And that is just part of the explanation of why we paid too much last year.
Dudley Maier
Highgate
Trees please
I SEE that Vincent council has just adopted its new street tree policy with a preference for native species.
Great timing given the way the shot-hole borer is nibbling its way through exotic species, but I feel the policy is missing a vital part of the equation.
And that’s the understorey.
An urban forest should be just that – more than a canopy over our heads, but a biodiverse community of flora and fauna from the floor to the ceiling that we share our space with.
The majority of our birds live close to ground level.
James Johnson
Perth
A change of scene helps
IN 1993 I purchased a property in Crawley.
It is the same building that Eric Cook, the last person hanged in Western Australia, tried to murder a person.
That was unit 2, while I live in unit 1.
Thank goodness the tourist buses laden with ogling people with their cameras to “snap” the property for posterity have stopped.
As I live close to the Swan River yet do not have views of the lapping water and skyscrapers, I decided to acquire a scene of my home with the river and the Perth city sky scrapers in the background.
With the aid of an aeroplane as there were no drones hovering about, I had a laminated huge picture attached to sheeting made and fastened to my wall with jarrah beading.
That was in 2005 and now I watch the ever-changing city scenery and skyscrapers changing. Totally fascinating.

With the cost to purchase river and city views, it is a most economical way to at least “feel” that I am looking out onto the city. Should anyone ask me if I have uninterrupted views of the city and Swan River I always answer “yes” …although in reality the only uninterrupted views I have is of my car park!
I think of it as my Walter Mitty city view with the Swan River lapping.
However the good things is that I do not work five days a week in the city in one of those skyscrapers, as I do not understand why some people drive home from work and then look back at the office until it is time to return the next day for another day’s work.
That would be my definition of insanity.
However, this idea is potentially a great business opportunity for a skilful photographer with a drone.
Just imagine how many packaged land and house deals newly sighed would be screaming for a city view.
Forget about me the idea patenting the idea… just let every creative home buyer and tenant enjoy.
Now having said that, perhaps the rent will increase by $100 per week when tenants are already struggling to make ends meet.
Murray Pitsikas
Crawley