No alarms in empty hostel

THE former caretaker of Hostel Milligan is concerned there’s no fire alarms or detectors in place to proof the building against another blaze, and the council doesn’t require any. 

Tony Ransom ran the hostel there until the owners, Singapore-based Fragrance Group, ceased his lease in 2019 to make way for a double-tower redevelopment that’s yet to start. 

The building was supposed to be secured by the owner under a heritage agreement signed by Fragrance, Perth city council, and the WA Heritage Council. But it wasn’t secure enough and after months of break-ins, a fire damaged the innards in March.

At last week’s Perth city council meeting Mr Ransom lodged a question, first noting: “Thankfully the fire department extinguished the significant fire which would otherwise have become a massive inferno in the heritage-listed Milligan Hostel/Pearl Villa last week.

“Can you advise if the building is still protected with 30 smoke detectors, two heat detectors, emergency alarm lights and alarm bells being active?

“Or is the building now unprotected, with power to the detectors now being disconnected? If disconnected, how does the council now match the previous protection?”

Council CEO Michelle Reynolds responded: “The building is declared as non-habitable by the city and therefore cannot be occupied. All access points remain permanently sealed. Persons illegally entering the building, actually breaking and entering, is a matter for local police.

“As the building is declared non-habitable and is to remain unoccupied (vacant) there is no requirement to have an operational fire system in place. All services to the building have been disconnected.”

That’s in line with DFES recommendation to switch off all utilities to deter break-ins and reduce the risk of fire, but the catch is that wired smoke alarms become useless. 

When Mr Ransom showed us around the building in 2019 he pointed out they had an arsenal of fire extinguishers at the ready in case of any fire, and council inspectors regularly visited to ensure all fire-preventing gear was up to standard. 

Shortly after the fire when we spoke to Fragrance’s local agent, architect Laurie Scanlan, he told us they were doing everything they could to secure the place.

We queried if it’d have been more secure just leaving the hostel tenants in place until closer to the development date. Mr Scanlan said work was supposed to start much sooner and the original start date had been delayed due to “Covid; these are things we couldn’t have imagined” and his focus now is on keeping it secured.

Ms Reynolds also told councillors “a structural engineer was engaged, at the city’s request, by the property owner and found that the recent fire did not damage the heritage elements of the building” including the villa, which is to be kept as part of the redevelopment approval. 


One response to “No alarms in empty hostel

  1. No Fire had been lit at Milligan Hostel since 1930 nor Pearl Villa since 1887 other than fires in the fireplaces and laundry copper in the back yard until 2021. There will be at least a dozen Powder Filled Fire extinguishers in the building as there were about 25 of which one was tested and filmed in 2019. There are also 30 hard wired smoke detectors which had individual internal battery backup.
    2 hard wired Heat Detectors are in Caddy Cafe below wired to , a Visual Flashing Light and Audible BELL alarm which Kings Park Electrical connected probably soley to the Electricity Main Meter –

    If people living OFF THE GRID can have Solar Powered Smoke Detectors – why cant Rare Composite Heritage Buildings be worthy of the same meagre investment – even in Western Australias CAPITAL CITY’ – Not worth the Cost, or Not worth the Thinking about?

    $400,000,000 Perth Museum, to house ancient artefacts -Yet Evidence of how young the City of Perth is, in comparison – With over 1000 residents in relatively close proximity, and the cooler months approaching and Milligan Hostel now deemed by the CEO officially Not To Need Fire Protection – but surely all those RATE PAYING RESIDENTS are entitled to Smoke Prevention or at least Audible Warning???

    Any attempt at Arson would have FAILED, if the residents had remained, as the policy had always been to take in those who found the place, until they could fend for themselves. We always carried at least 10% of those who needed help, and those beyond help. particular who had fallen through all the cracks in the system. Harry Anesty who lived in Pearl Villa before the Perth Mint, assayed minerals in his laboratory with a 60 foot chimney – on Land on St Georges Tce. had the same discrete policy, and when Assaying for those who could afford, would also put some mineral samples in for the poorer folk, helping reduce the harshness of their lives. Who thoughtlessly? insisted? the electric meter (to the Fire Detection Equipment) to be disconnected.. Let All Heritage Assessed Buildings have hard wired, or Solar Smoke Detectors – that homeless, regardless of who they might have been – that happen to have found shelter, can rest easy, that they will at least have warning if the building they are in is to be burned.. Everybody has parents, siblings, cousins – children..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s