• Council shuts book as DIY saves homes
    Residents say they bought $750 of sandbags (below) and spent hours clearing drains (above) to keep the flooding at bay in 2021. The council now says it’s case closed because the water didn’t reach their homes.

    AS the rainy season approaches, residents living around Beatty Park Reserve fear their houses will again be flooded if Vincent council doesn’t fix drainage problems pronto. 

    Homes just north of the park were badly inundated in the 2010 storms. An overwhelmed drainage network, leaves and mulch from Beatty Park clogging the stormwater grates, and the homes being in a low spot that cops water from the aquatic centre carpark all contributed to the flooding.

    Never finished

    The council made some fixes to upgrade pipes, raise kerbing and partially build a retaining wall to slow the flow and trap debris from getting into the drains. The wall was recommended by an expert consultant’s report in 2017, but it was never finished.

    But the water was still lapping at homes in the wetter spells in 2016, 2017 and 2021: “We are still getting flooded,” resident Ray Stevenson says.

    Mr Stevenson and other residents headed to the 2022 AGM imploring the council to take action and finish the retaining wall. 

    Their motion will be considered by councillors at the April 5 meeting, but a staff recommendation to councillors advises against any further action.

    The report says they’ve already spent more than $260,000 on flood mitigation around Beatty Park, and they have three other flood-prone areas to focus on.

    The report points out the homes didn’t flood during the hard rain of May 2021.

     

    But residents Suzanne and Steve Burke say the only reason their home didn’t flood last year was because they took action themselves.

    Ahead of the 2021 wet season they spent $750 on sandbags to temporarily complete the retaining wall, and then spent rainy days making sure the drains were clear.

    In a letter to council the Burkes wrote “during this major rain event, Steve spent several hours outside in the storm continually unblocking drains so that they continued to drain the water. 

    Personal safety

    “This is the only reason our homes were not flooded. [Vincent] admin now claim that the drains worked and ignore this fact that they only drained because Steve put his personal safety at risk to protect our homes. This is not sustainable for us.” 

    At this week’s council briefing, councillors requested more information ahead of the full meeting on April 5, wanting to know how often the drains are cleared and how much it’d cost to finish the wall. 

    Mayor Emma Cole raised the Burkes’ point that they’d only been spared a flooding by their own desperate efforts and asked staff for answers on that. 

    If nothing’s done locals reckon this year might be a bad one. There’s more hard ground at Beatty Park Reserve compared to when the expert’s report was written in 2017: The pavilion that blocked some water has been demolished, and large areas of the park have been converted from grass to gravel gardens.

    “We feel like we are sitting ducks,” the Burkes said.

  • Verge toll audit
    One among hundreds of recently expired verge trees.

    AFTER a wave of verge trees keeled over in Perth’s recent heatwave, an audit will be carried out across Bayswater to assess the toll and find out how to keep the survivors alive.

    Bayswater has some of the highest levels of hard “grey” surfaces such as pavement in the country, ripe to capture sunlight and exacerbate hot spells.

    Councillor Elli Petersen-Pik had noticed a lot of trees perishing this summer and put a call out to residents asking them to notify council about any they’d seen, and notifications about hundreds of dead trees quickly rolled in. 

    “We have just experienced the hottest summer on record in Perth, and unfortunately, it seems like an unprecedented number of our verge trees, including mature ones, have not survived it,” Cr Petersen-Pik said.

    “Each mature verge tree that dies is a massive loss to our city, not only environmentally and socially, but also financially, not least because a lot of effort and money have been invested in each one of them over the years.”

    At the March 23 meeting he moved a motion calling for a report on the number of trees that died this summer, seeking details of vulnerable species and the suspected cause.

    The motion also calls for an account of how frequently they’re watered, and seeks any measures to keep them alive in future hot spells.

    “We have hundreds, from what I understand now from the feedback that I have receiving … we have a massive loss of verge trees during the last summer.

    “I received emails from everywhere: Noranda, Morley, Embleton, Bedford, Maylands, everywhere. It’s across the board.

    “And people want to know how the city’s maintaining those trees when it comes to watering… how we are actually ensuring they survive the heat, the changing climate.

    “We are losing mature trees, which is the most concerning thing, big trees that should survive.”

    Inner city trees also suffered through the hot spell, with many London planes in the CBD losing  chunks out of their canopies across December and January. Stirling council’s attempt at planting new trees along Walter Road was also quickly undone with scores in December. Vincent council’s next tree mortality report covering the summer comes out next month. 

    by DAVID BELL

  • City Clean Machine a hit
    Lord mayor Basil Zempilas with the CBD’s new Clean Machine.

    AN on-call cleaning cart scooting around the CBD has proved so popular it’ll have its patrol extended.

    Perth council brought in the solar-powered ‘Clean Machine’ (a repurposed golf cart) last September for a trial that coincided with AFL grand final week.

    It was immediately popular and during the trial 120 businesses or visitors called the hotline or asked the operator to spot-clean messes as they popped up rather than waiting for scheduled cleans.

    But it’s been on a short leash, patrolling just the city malls and part of Northbridge around James Street.

    This week lord mayor Basil Zempilas announced the clean machine would spread its horizons due to popular demand.

    “The anecdotal evidence and other correspondence into the city has been that people really enjoy it, they like the service, they contact us regularly.

    “What has become particularly evident is that people like to walk up to the operator of the clean machine and say ‘hello mate, how are you going, there’s a bit of a mess just around the corner, could you come with me?’, and the operator has been more than happy to oblige. 

    “As a result of the excellent service and the excellent reception it has had the city admin has extended the service”, taking in more of Hay and Murray Streets, Wellington Street up to the Perth Arena, and Roe Street in Northbridge. 

    The Clean Machine has been a pretty coffer-friendly option for the council, costing them about $34,000 for four months’ service last year. 

    In December complaints by Northbridge traders about the grotty, chewing-gum ridden state of their streets and paths prompted the council to spend an extra $80,000 a year on monthly heavy duty street cleanings along James Street. 

  • Hub opens doors – and fixes them
    A Hub trial skills workshop. Photo by Melissa Cashman.

    WOMEN will get their own tool library and workshop in Bayswater, the first dedicated women’s shed in the state.

    The Bayswater Women’s Hub has fixed a five-year lease with Bayswater council to move into the long-vacant building kiosk, changerooms and bunker at Shearn Memorial Park in Maylands. 

    The not-for-profit group ran some trial tool skills workshops in temporary venues last year but have been on a long search for a proper home.

    Hub chair Michelle Slater told the March council briefing: “Our mission is to provide access to tools and workshop facilities in a community space and to facilitate the exchange of knowledge between cultures, generations, and capabilities.

    “Our vision is to empower the women of Bayswater and beyond. We aim to achieve this by our two initiatives: A community tool library and a women’s workshop.”

    Hub member Denise Pepper, a local artist and sculptor, said learning to use tools was a pivotal moment in her life and she wanted other women to have the same opportunity. 

    “I went and studied a home handyperson course and I learned how to use tools. And I didn’t realise at the time that the minute I picked up that drill something actually evoked and awoke inside of me. It wasn’t until later that I realised what that was.

    “That gave me the confidence… to change a fuse wire, fix that broken chair, have a bit of confidence in the house and also be in a situation where I don’t have to have a handyman come in and fix things. I can be independent.”

    The five-year lease at Shearn Memorial Park lease stemmed from a motion by councillor Elli Petersen-Pik, who said at last week’s meeting: “I personally was very moved by the story of Denise Pepper. I think it was quite inspirational and I hope we’ll all be able to hear stories of other women, what they got from this place and how we helped them to grow.”

    When they first found the spot it was in clear need of some love. The space had long ago hosted sports teams, and old blueprints show the layout held two lots of male toilets, two male changerooms, and a small double-loo for women off to the side.

    “When we initially opened that bunker it was like walking into a scene from Indiana Jones,” Ms Slater said.

    “There were cobwebs, and creatures scuttled off into the distance. But I saw it with love-heart shaped eyes, because it was the perfect size for our storage requirements.

    “We could see behind the faded graffiti to see what it was going to become”.

    It’ll be the first dedicated space for a women’s shed in WA. Stirling councillor Elizabeth Re has been trying to get her council to set one up, but so far they’ve stopped short of a full women’s shed and are just running skills workshops on lighter tools in a shared space. She’s still pushing for a permanent spot.

    Denise Pepper and Michele Slater. Photo by Bridget Turner.

    ARTIST DENISE PEPPER gave an impassioned speech to Bayswater councillors to help secure the Women’s Hub a five-year lease. Here are some excerpts.

    I FOUND myself in an  unusual but also very awkward situation at age 24 of being a single mother with two children.

    I had so many things to learn, let alone “how do I look after my house”.

    So I realised I needed to do something about this, and I went and studied a home handyperson course and I learned how to use tools. 

    And I didn’t realise at the time that the minute I picked up that drill something actually evoked and awoke inside of me. It wasn’t until later that I realised what that was.

    That gave me the confidence … to change a fuse wire, fix that broken chair, have a bit of confidence in the house and also be in a situation where I don’t have to have a handyman come in and fix things. 

    I can be independent.

    From thereon things changed. I never actually finished high school, so reading and writing was always a difficult thing for me. 

    So I also then went off and studied building construction because of that workshop.

    I worked in the building trade for a number of years. 

    I purchased my own home, I did my extensions on my own home. 

    I got lots of editorials about this woman who has done this extension herself.

    From there I ended up going to university, not knowing that I’d ever get into university because I never finished high school. 

    I got in on a portfolio exemption. 

    So from there I end up working at this university, and I’m still there, working and teaching how to use tools, how to create art, and now I have a career … from that day, picking up that tool and learning to use that tool, my life has changed. 

    If I had never had that workshop I wouldn’t be standing here today. It’s really important for me, now, as a 62-year-old woman, to do that full circle.

    I now want to teach women who are in domestic violence, relocating, starting over, I want those women to have that empowerment. 

    I want them to feel confident, I want them to feel they’re in their own home, they don’t have to call a handyman. 

    They can do it for themselves. This is about empowerment for women, this is why this women’s hub is so important.

  • Wonderful play 
    Playwright Dan Giovannoni with co-creator and director Luke Kerridge at rehearsal for The Great Un-Wondering of Wilbur Whittaker. Photo by Anthony Tran

    THERE comes a time when the pressures of life can start to erode the wide-eyed joy and creativity you took for granted as a child.

    This happens to the protagonist in the play The Great Un-Wondering of Wilbur Whittaker, who by middle-age has conformed to the 9-5 and his dreary, sensible life in the suburbs.

    But Wilbur still has a little shoebox of “wonders” from his childhood that he keeps under the bed, until one night The Bureau – a recycling agency for long forgotten wonderings – confiscate it.

    The next day, Wilbur starts to slowly disappear and must embark on a fantastical adventure to the outer reaches of the galaxy to rediscover his “wonder”.

    The Great Un-Wondering of Wilbur Whittaker was co-created by playwright Dan Giovannoni and director Luke Kerridge, the award-winning team behind smash-hit plays HOUSE and Bambert’s Book of Lost Stories.

    Giovannoni says Wilbur’s intergalatic odyssey will definately appeal to people who have experienced the worst of lockdown and isolation.

    “Covid definitely clipped our wings in terms of travel, but also maybe more profoundly the wings that let our imaginations go wandering,” he says.

    “Wilbur’s adventure into outer space is as much a journey into the galaxies inside his own heart as it is about hurtling on comets through the stars (though that does happen too!)

    “I reckon a flight of fancy can be as enriching as a flight to another place.”

    Juggling nostalgia, science fiction and midlife crisis, the play is reminiscent of the best and most moving The Twilight Zone episodes like Walking Distance and A Stop at Willoughby. Like The Twilight Zone creator Rod Serling, Giovannoni says it’s best to have one foot in the present and the other in the past.

    “Ideally you meet in the middle! That shoebox can always be open, if you let it – it doesn’t have to be something you just dip in to from time to time,” he says.

    “Grown-ups still hold all the wisdom they innately held as children, so you don’t need to be a big kid – you are a big kid.”

    The interstellar plot proved challenging for Kerridge, who had to be super creative with his direction and stage design to keep the audience in the moment.

    “I often say I like to try and do impossible things on stage but this show has taken it to a whole new level,” Kerridge says. “The most challenging aspect is it changes location every scene. We wanted to make a grand adventure story on stage so it has taken all of our collective imaginations working in overdrive to make it feel like you do in fact go on a journey across the galaxy.”

    The seeds of Giovannoni and Kerridge’s successful creative partnership were sown during a tram journey in Melbourne many years ago.

    Imagination

    “We had come from seeing the same show and were dissecting it,” Kerridge says

    “During the conversation he said ‘I think you are my theatrical soul mate’. Reflecting on that conversation all these years later, he may have been right. It’s very much a harmonious partnership – we have similar tastes and ambitions, we love the same sort of stories. We love bouncing ideas off each other, stretching our imaginations and making each other laugh.”

    A Barking Gecko Theatre production, the play is for both adults and children: “This is a story for everyone, and asks children and grown-ups to meet in the middle. People often ask about this challenge and assume the solution is ‘chucking a joke in’ for the adults every now and then. But really I think the secret is acknowledging and playing to the intelligence of children,” Kerridge says.

    The Great Un-Wondering of Wilbur Whittaker is at the Heath Ledger Theatre from April 9-16. More info and tix at barkinggecko.com.au

  • Letters 4.2.22

    The lightbulb moment that never was 

    WHILE it is great news that about one third of Vincent is likely to get underground power, the community should not be under any illusion that this is a result of anything initiated by the Vincent council or administration – it is purely a response to an offer from Western Power.

    The recent history of undergrounding of power is a tale of inaction and deaf ears. It starts in 2017 when mayor Emma Cole committed to developing a plan for underground power and taking it to the community as part of her election pitch. Nothing appears to have come of that. 

    Then in 2020 the community passed an AGM motion asking the city to develop a long-term financial plan for putting the power underground through the whole city – a plan based on the Subiaco model which saw the project completed over a 38-year period, and paid for by a very modest rate increase. 

    The administration did not support the idea – too much work or too difficult, I guess.  

    And a ‘do nothing’ council went along with the administration.

    The same motion was passed by the community at the 2021 AGM.

    The administration gave a similar ‘do nothing’ answer, however this time the council asked them to investigate further. 

    However, it looks like all the administration did was appoint some consultants to look at the issue, but only after Western Power approached the city with a new method for paying for underground power.

    So we now have an opportunity, initiated by Western Power, which will see about one third of the city getting underground power at an average cost of about $3,500.  

    Fantastic news for people like me, but what about the rest of the city? 

    There is no plan, there is no vision. 

    We should contrast what has happened in Vincent with our local government neighbours in Subiaco and Cambridge. 

    Their councils adopted proactive approaches which have resulted in all their power being underground. 

    In Vincent we have a plan for about one third of the city, but nothing more.

    It demonstrates the difference between being pro-active and being re-active. 

    The city could have been prepared if the mayor actually did what she said she would do in 2017, and if the administration actually listened to the community in 2020.

    To make matters worse, the administration is proposing to increase rates by $1-2 million next year before they even work out how the project is going to be funded. 

    If they finally adopt a user-pays approach, will they pay back the $1-2 million overpaid rates?

    And what about the owners in the Highgate east area who paid to have their power put underground about 15 years ago – why do they have to pay again via a rates increase?

    Tellingly, the staff are also saying that 94 per cent of people recently surveyed as part of the review of the Strategic Community Plan say they rate underground power as a high priority, even though it didn’t get a single mention in the 2018 plan.

    It is not that the community sentiment has changed, it is because the city did not listen to the feedback in the first place – something that has become the norm in recent years.

    The future of underground power is in the hands of the council. 

    They either adopt a proactive approach and develop a comprehensive model for the whole city, or they take the easy route and just leave it to happenstance.

    Dudley Maier
    Highgate

    Anyone can fall prey to scammers

    EVERY human being can be scammed.

    Make no mistake about it.

    Scammers are everywhere, lurking around to catch you out, particularly on internet sex and dating sites.

    They like to target vulnerable individuals like lonely old ugly men with one foot in the grave.

    They offer hope, confidence, security, prosperity, happiness.

    They give you the opposite. You cannot find a scammer, they find you and hang on like crazy – until you unload your cash savings into their account.

    They appear unexpected like an angel of light.

    When the going gets tough they are gone.

    They are gutless bastards always hidden and disguised.

    Chronic liars always. Argumentative, determined, rude, arrogant, demanding without fear or concern.

    Right or wrong means nothing.

    They are focused on robbery. You cannot win an argument with them or even a scuffle.

    They cannot be reasoned with. Report them to police at your own peril – no sympathy from them.

    “Not interested,” they will say, “you acted foolishly following their suggestions.”

    When all is said and done they have not broken any laws.

    Scammers do not appear face-to-face or on camera.

    You will not see their handwriting, hear their voices or see a genuine photograph.

    Any bit of information you pick up will be vague and false.

    They use fake photos and steal other people’s names and identity.

    One example is Samantha Salas.

    There could be a million people in the world with that name who are genuine – twice as many are pretending.

    They love to use Google hangouts which covers a multitude of sin.

    Like a pawn broker, scammers know what they are hiding and you don’t.

    Frankly, they do not give a damn.

    With regard to sex workers generally, many of them are not in the industry at all.

    They are play actors and good at it.

    They can identify your weaknesses and know how you will respond when they touch a raw nerve.

    The recognise your lustful thoughts and emotions.

    My advice to scammers is: 

    “Get a God-centred life”. Repent.

    And to those who have been or will be scammed, remember God created a magnificent angel of light called Lucifer who unfortunately became the enemy Satan the devil.

    In the world to this very day wandering around seeking who he may devour.

    Don’t let it be you – pray to God that he will protect you from this roaring lion.

    Seek not the powers of darkness, seek true light from the world’s saviour Jesus Christ and him crucified.

    Raymond Conder
    Perth

  • Inner peace 

    IMAGINE living in a top-notch inner city home with plenty of room and a decent garden?

    It sounds fanciful, but this three bedroom two bathroom Bulwer Street house ticks all those boxes and is a real stunner.

    Things get off to a great start with a classic facade, decorative security screen and stained glass front door.

    The ante is raised inside with one of those lovely period hallways with rooms either side and chandeliers funnelling you towards the main living area, which features polished jarrah floorboards, high ceilings and decorative cornices.

    The kitchen is an absolute stunner – glossy, jet-black handleless cupboards and drawers create a seamless futuristic look with the units almost blending into the walls.

    Completing the 22nd century look is sleek stainless steel appliances and classy marble-style tiles.It really is a beauty with plenty of room for a circular kitchen/dining table.

    Off to the side, through a large opening, is a cute lounge where the owners have a funky L-shaped couch and middle eastern rug.

    A snug little zone to chill out with your loved one and the family.

    The bathrooms have got the same wow factor as the kitchen and have been finished to an amazing standard with gorgeous, large floor-to-ceiling tiles that are redolent of a five-star hotel suite.

    The owners clearly have a great sense of style and have renovated this property with aplomb.

    The polished jarrah floorboards contrast beautifully with the neutral colour scheme in the three chic bedrooms, which all have built-in robes and roller shutters.

    In a stylish touch, one bedroom has an original fireplace that enhances the property’s heritage credentials.

    We all know the drawback to inner-city living is the lack of garden and having to compromise on a courtyard.

    Well, not at this house – out the back is a massive sheltered deck overlooking a large swathe of grass.So you have an entertaining area as well as lots of grass for kids to play on and pets to stretch their legs.

    It really is a rarity to find a garden like this in a property so close to the city centre, and you can actually see the tops of the skyscrapers from the elevated deck.

    The home includes air-conditioning throughout, a massive laundry, electric gate, garden shed and secure off-street parking for a small car, plus three permits.

    Situated on a 304sqm green-titled block on Bulwer Street, you are a couple of streets back from Hyde Park and a short walk from all the cafes, restaurants and pubs in North Perth, Beaufort Street, the city and Northbridge.

    It’s also in the Highgate Primary and Mount Lawley High catchment areas.

    This stunning abode would be perfect for a professional couple who like to entertain or a small family who want to live close to the city.

    Buyers over $949,000311
    Bulwer Street, Perth
    ACTON Mt Lawley 9272 2488
    Agent Carlos Lehn 0416 206 

  • Pedestrians passed over
    Don’t Divide Maylands members hoped for a better deal for walkers and riders. Photo by Tim Burns

    THE Caledonian Avenue crossing in Maylands will close this coming Easter weekend, with hopes for a pedestrian underpass now dashed.

    The state government says closing the crossing is “necessary for the Forrestfield-Airport Link” track upgrades which will see more trains along that line. Closing it to cars isn’t too controversial since it’s already constantly clogged and traffic backs up way down the street when the boom gates close: that’s around four hours each day.

    The closure will cost $15 million and nearby intersections are being upgraded for cars to get across more easily, but the government’s paltry plan to detour pedestrians and cyclists has disappointed locals. 

    350m walk

    It’s a 350-metre walk to the next nearest pedestrian crossing under the Maylands train station.

    Local group Don’t Divide Maylands campaigned to keep the crossing open to walkers and riders, ideally as an underpass.

    But this week transport minister Rita Saffioti announced the crossing’s end on the Easter weekend with no plans to resurrect pedestrian access. 

    There’ll be “improved pedestrian facilities at Guildford Road and Eighth Avenue” and some TBA protected bike lanes on Railway Parade to help cyclists ride up to the next station, and some fixes 

    for the Maylands station underpass to let riders through more easily than having to haul bikes down stairs.

    But the underpass was deemed too expensive, a ministerial media statement says: “Feasibility work undertaken by Main Roads has found that the construction of another underpass at the Caledonian Avenue crossing will cost approximately $26m.”

    In November 2021 Bayswater councillor Elli Petersen-Pik moved a motion that his council write to the minister to express “the council’s strong opposition to the state government’s plan to block pedestrian and bike rider access – and request that provision of such access be included in the plans, with a preference for a well-lit and safe underpass”.

    He pointed out that back in the 2017 election Labor said they’d spend between $50m to $70m to close the crossing. That would have easily paid for a pedestrian underpass, but instead they’re spending just $15m on a total closure. 

    This week Cr Petersen-Pik said “the decision to close the crossing, without adequate alternatives in place, is disappointing, short-sighted and will have major implications for residents and businesses”.

    He says it undoes efforts to get more people out of their cars.

    “Cutting off access for bike riders and pedestrians goes against the state government’s own Long-Term Cycle Network, published only last year, as well as the City [of Bayswater]’s Bike Plan. 

    “It will permanently entrench the railway line as an even worse barrier to walking within the Maylands Activity Centre, and limit pedestrian access to businesses. Those with mobility issues will be impacted the most.”

    by DAVID BELL

  • Wall to wall colour

    A NEW street art festival’s coming to cover the Mount Lawley’s cafe strip in murals next month.

    The inaugural No More Blank Walls festival’s bringing a bunch of local artists together for live mural painting, street art tours, a gallery exhibition and artist talks.

    It’s been organised by local street art company Blank Walls, and cofounder Will Clark says “putting on our own street art festival has been a goal of ours since we started Blank Walls back in 2019.

    “With everything going on in the world right now, there’s no better time to turn some blank spaces into beautiful places.”

    Stirling council’s helped fund 

    it, and mayor Mark Irwin says he hopes “these murals will become cultural assets that will provide long-term benefits to the community and businesses in the area long after the festival”.

    Paintings are planned across April 8 to 16 around the Mount Lawley.

  • ‘Holey shiiii..’
    • Courtney Langer’s scooter came to a crunching halt when it hit this pretty dicey-looking road repair. 

    Rider goes flying over dodgy pothole repair

    A MT HAWTHORN resident has been left with a $1000 ambulance bill, lost work, a potential permanent disability and a broken scooter after coming a cropper on some pretty ordinary-looking road repairs in Vincent.

    Courtney Langer was on his way to visit his brother in Bourke Street, Leederville on March 8 when out of the blue his scooter suddenly stopped and he was flung onto the road, suffering a radial fracture of his elbow.

    When Mr Langer went to check on what had caused the accident, he was furious.

    On smoko

    “What they have done is they have attempted to fill a pothole; they’ve drilled into the road … and then poured in a little tar, but they’ve left a huge great dent in the road which blends in so you can’t see it,” he said.

    “There was no barricade and no signage; it was like they went on smoko.”

    Mr Langer said the pain from his fractured elbow was excruciating.

    “I’m living on Panadeine Forte constantly, and they are saying ‘you could end up with a permanent disability’.

    “It’s disgusting; I am on a part pension but I do some work and I haven’t even been able to ride my pushy.”

    Mr Langer said he called the council and workers came out the next day to highlight the site with a white marker, but when he broached the subject of council liability he got a brusque response he feels was pretty unsympathetic given the circumstances.

    The possibility of an insurance claim also seemed to have got the wind up the council when the Voice sent some questions in, as it wouldn’t comment on whether the repair was done in-house or by a contractor, or if anything might have contributed to the dip other than shoddy repair work.

    But CEO David MacLennan said the city was concerned to hear about the accident 

    and hoped Mr Langer was recovering.

    “In this instance, we became aware of an issue when it was reported by Mr Langer and the fault has since been rectified.

    “We understand Mr Langer intends to submit an insurance claim with the city, although this has not yet occurred.

    “Any claim will be referred to the city’s insurers and we are unable to comment further under those circumstances.”