• Letters 20.3.21

    Hands off heritage

    THE demolition of iconic buildings often goes by quietly to avoid community outrage.

    This has been the case in the destruction of many sites of significant cultural and historic significance. The motive behind this so-called development is always profit and greed.

    Historically the CFMEU has played an important role in green-bans. The most significant was the struggle to save iconic places in NSW where Jack Mundey passed into posterity for having led a heroic struggle in saving these iconic places and to his credit this has shaped what Sydney looks like today.

    A state funeral for Mundey on Wednesday March 10 in Sydney highlighted, what he as an environmentalist and a militant trade unionist was able to achieve.

    The construction union has a role to play in saving our heritage which will help to ensure a connected past and future to enrich the future for our children and the people of WA.

    It was with outrage that we recently found out that the iconic building located at 123 Claisebrook Road, East Perth was recently demolished despite community concerns.

    As reported by the West Australian the building was put up for sale by former owner Performing Arts of WA who seemed unable to keep up the premises due to the cuts to its government grants. 

    Melissa Callanan was quoted in the West Australian on May 25, 2016 saying: “The timing was bad. We had quite a few challenges, so we sought external advice and decided to liquidate the asset and we are exploring starting an endowment fund to support WA artists”.

    Both state and local governments should be more active in the upkeep and protection of buildings of heritage value.

    In the case of 123 Claisebrook Road it was built in 1890 so 130 years of history has gone.

    On December 20, 2017 the City of Vincent approved 5-0 to “the partial demolition of existing buildings and construction of four storey mixed use buildings including one office and 12 multiple dwellings”.

    The reality is that only the old bricks were saved and will be used as a fake facade; the rest of the building was destroyed.

    The union is not against development but it stands up for the protection of our heritage and the preservation of iconic buildings like its new home at Perth Trades Hall which is back in the hands of those who built it.

    Vinnie Molina
    CFMEU Organiser
    Beaufort St, Perth 

    Code red: Gone AWOL

    UNTIL 2017 the Vincent Code of Conduct had a requirement for all council members to return calls or emails from community members within a specified time period.

    In December 2017 this was [quietly] removed from the Code of Conduct. 

    The report that council considered in 2017 gave no indication to the community that the requirement was to be removed. There was no copy of the code with tracked changes provided so we could see what was removed, and the report to council listed just five areas that were being removed from the Code, none of which was the requirement to respond to the community.

    Interestingly the report also said that all council members had reviewed and had provided feedback on the revised Code.

    I only became aware of these changes after I heard from a number of community members that council members were not responding to correspondence.

    I was telling them that the Code of Conduct required a response, so I decided to investigate to make sure that was still true, and that’s when I found out it had been removed.

    Move forward to 2021 and the Vincent Annual General Meeting of Electors. A motion to reinstate this provision into the Code of Conduct, and to advertise the Code for public comment was passed by the community.

    Because of changes to Regulations the City has come up with a new Code of Conduct.

    However, the staff have not included any requirement to respond to the community, and they are recommending that it does not even get advertised for public comment.

    The administration’s report did not even address the issue.

    So much for listening to the community – it seems to be a lost art.

    It will be interesting to see if any council member has the courage to reinstate the requirement to respond to the community, and to advertise the Code for public comment when they meet next Tuesday. I’m not holding my breath.

    Dudley Maier
    Highgate

  • Making its Mark

    WITH WA turning a deep shade of red on Saturday night, I almost expected to see Mark McGowan levitating above Perth like some political deity. 

    No such joy, but for a minute I thought I glimpsed John Carey in a microlight, carpet bombing the city with red Lego bricks.

    Sanity prevailed when my family and I arrived at Grill’d, a stylish burger bar on the corner of Oxford and Newcastle Streets in Leederville.

    With its large neon sign, Grill’d reminded me of a classic 1950s American diner, and I could almost smell the Brylcreem on Fonzie’s hair.

    In a congested burger market, Grill’d’s point of difference is ‘healthy’ eating – making burgers with zero artificial colours, flavours and preservatives, as well as using grass-fed beef, free- range eggs and RSPCA-approved chicken.

    But are their burgers any good? Well yes, and I’m big fan of the outlet in Fremantle, so I wanted to check if the Leederville one was just as good.

    The menu had a good range of beef, chicken, lamb, wagyu and veggie burgers, covering everything from the humble cheeseburger to the premium wagyu pattie with truffle mayo.

    No token veggie burger here, with the menu including an impressive 10 plant-based incarnations. You could also build your own burger, and there was a small range of salads and a nice variety of sides.

    My Mustard and Pickled ($13.50) had a warm glow courtesy of the Dijon mustard and dill pickles.

    There was nothing too daring in this burger – it was like a big, vintage gas-guzzling Cadillac that never gets above 50 on the freeway – but it ticked all the flavour boxes with cos lettuce, tomato, Spanish onions and tomato relish.

    Grill’d’s burgers aren’t like a fatty, leaning tower of Pisa, and you can comfortably pick them up without the innards jettisoning out the sides and the bun disintegrating into a soggy mess.

    The beef patty was slightly over for my liking (I like it a bit pink in the middle) but it was a satisfying burger.

    Across the table my wife was enjoying her Bird and Brie ($14.50).

    “The cranberry sauce is a great touch and goes perfectly with the decadent rich cheese,” she said.

    “The chicken is very slightly over, but the herb mayo and tomato keep things nice and moist.”

    Our zucchini chips ($8.90 large) were super chunky specimens with a crumbed coating and heaps of sea salt.

    I liked how they left the skin on, adding a rustic texture to the soft, piping-hot flesh.

    Unfortunately there was way too much seasoning, and after a few chips it felt like I was licking the walls of a Siberian salt mine. 

    I liked the concept though. 

    The kids’ “Mini Me” pack ($9.50) included a cheese burger, fries and juice or water.

    The chips were seasoned with rosemary, which I always think is a bit of a gamble for nippers, but mine didn’t seem to mind and wolfed everything down.

    The portion size was just right for aged seven and under.

    I ordered two tomato sauces for the kids, which unfortunately the staff forgot, and I had to go up to the counter. 

    Grill’d Leederville wasn’t quite up to the super high standards I had experienced at the Fremantle outlet, but their burgers were still a strong 8 out of 10 and easily surpass a lot of the competition.

    Maybe one day Mark will walk across Lake Monger and come into Leederville to try one.

    Grill’d – Leederville
    128 Oxford St
    grilld.com.au

    by STEPHEN POLLOCK

     

  • WA’s finest  
    Artwork by Melissa Clements feature in this year’s Fine Art exhibition at Perth College in Mt Lawley.

    MELISSA CLEMENTS is one of the homegrown success stories featured in next weekend’s Fine Art exhibition at Perth College.

    A former Perth College art captain in 2016, Clements won the Visual Arts ATAR that year, opened the Fine Art exhibition in 2017, and went on to study in New York and Florence before returning to Perth a few years ago, where she held her first solo exhibition Fracture.

    Specialising in hyper-real portraits, Clements adds an eerie and slightly futuristic bent to the style of old masters like Caravaggio and Rembrandt.

    Displaying alongside Clements will be 60 emerging and established artists from WA, including the likes of Crispin Akerman, Kay Gibson and Jacinda Bayne.

    “2020 has presented new challenges, and in the process, reinforced to all who proudly call Western Australia home, how immensely fortunate we are,” says event organisers. 

    “As we return to traveling and exploring our great state – from our far north to the old forests of the south coast and the vast eastern deserts to our golden sunsets – our Fine Art at Perth College Exhibition will introduce and showcase artists from all across the state, to encapsulate and ignite the human spirit in WA.”

    If sculpting is your thing, then make sure you check out the works of Martin Jaine, who makes all kinds of fascinating pieces out of recycled materials – even a rhinoceros. Jaine has had a serpentine career, working as a farmer, builder and antiques dealer, before starting sculpting as a hobby.

    It proved so successful it’s now his full time job, working out of Earlsferry House in Bassendean.

    They’ll also be a number of College alumni, former staff and parents exhibiting, including ex-staffer Robin Wells, who specialises in fine jewellery.

    Wells uses layered embossing and heavily oxidised metal in her peices, which reflects humankind’s impact on nature.

    Some have designs with blackened landscapes ravaged by fire – like ghostly echoes of the flora and fauna.

    The 36th Fine Art exhibition at Perth College in Mt Lawley is on next weekend (March 27 – 28) with Friday’s opening night featuring a champagne reception with live music from Perth College students.

    For more details go to fineartatperthcollege.com

    by STEPHEN POLLOCK

  • Vintage touch

    WHEN I heard the owner of this Perth home was a well-known antiques dealer, I hoped it was going to be full of individuality and bold twists and turns.

    I wasn’t disappointed.

    This three bedroom two bathroom abode has the owner’s eclectic fingers all over it, from the Art Nouveau leadlight windows to the moosehead on the stairwell.

    The staircase leading to the first floor is stunning – the bars on the wrought-iron balustrade resembles serpentine vines, curling around bannisters and weaving their way upwards. 

    It’s quite a feat of craftsmanship and I’ve never seen anything like it before.

    All this is framed by two beautiful leadlight windows, bathing the rich jarrah stairs in soft light.

    At the top of the stairs is the cherry on the top – a beautiful gold-coloured vaulted ceiling.

    The owners clearly committed to a style with no half-measures or indecision.

    This is illustrated by the black-and-white checkered floor tiles in the kitchen; it’s a daring statement and the kitsch factor is enhanced by the retro advertising signs and blue-framed cupboard doors.

    There’s even a set of swing doors with “Public Bar” stencilled into the frosted glass on the window panes. A cute little touch.

    Throughout the property there are gorgeous jarrah floors, complemented by vintage fireplaces and cathedral-like ceilings.

    The three bedrooms and two bathrooms are spilt over different levels, making the layout flexible and convenient if you have older kids or people coming to stay who want their own “level” and privacy.

    All the bedrooms are spacious with the huge main large enough to be split into two.

    On the turret top deck there is a relaxing living area and a sunroom with a tiled floor, which is now more of a stylish nook to have coffee during winter.

    From up here you have great panoramas of the city and the hills in the distance, making it a great spot for after-dinner drinks or social functions.

    Out the back the fairytale continues with a lovely cottage-style garden with brick walls and paving, raised garden beds and and lots of potted plants. It looks pretty, but is low maintenance for those who don’t have green fingers.

    This home includes a wine cellar, Juliet balconies and two parking spaces.

    Situated on a 298sqm block on Lindsay Street, this home is a short walk from The Brisbane Hotel, The Ellington Jazz Club, HBF park, and all the cafes and restaurants on Beaufort Street and in Northbridge.

    This is a one-of-a-kind home in a great locale.

    EOI welcome
    Viewing by appointment
    61 Lindsay Street, Perth
    Mark Hay Realty 9225 7000
    Daniel Porcaro 0437 281 938 

  • River fish deaths
    Fisher Mitch has about 50 years’ experience and was confident the fish he’d caught were healthy. Photo by David Bell.

    MORE than 600 dead fish were found in the Swan River near the Garratt Road bridge this week.

    Mostly bream, they were reported around the bridge and upstream on March 6, with the WA health department warning against fishing or even touching the water. 

    The health department says the cause and extent is still being investigated, but “significant rainfall and increased flows from the Avon River may have contributed to the fish kill. An increased amount of debris is also expected to float downstream in coming weeks following the large rainfall event.”

    The dead fish were gone as of Monday March 8 and signs warned “this water may cause ill effects to human and animals” and urging “no direct water contact activities”.

    The signs were few and far between; a seasoned fisher named Mitch didn’t spot them, but noticed an unusual orange tint to the water as he threw in a line. 

    He had some luck upstream of Garratt Road Bridge, pulling in two bream, saying his catch seemed unaffected and would make a good meal.

    “Look – healthy, strong,” he said despite the warning. 

    Mitch pointed out the water was the same earthy colour he recalled during a 2012 fish kill, when some 14,000 succumbed to algal blooms. 

    Algal blooms have also contributed to dolphin sickness and deaths – along with chemicals – while last year Murdoch university researchers linked high rainfall events to a deadly skin disease on the mammals likened to being burned by acid.

    After the 2012 die off the Swan River Trust prepared a report identifying a tangled web of problems. The river’s catchment area has been cleared for agriculture and development letting more contaminants and algae-causing nutrients flow downstream after rain. 

    That’s compounded by urban areas using chemicals and fertilisers, though Bayswater council’s won commendations for its efforts to treat stormwater before it hits the river. And the lower overall rainfall means reduced “environmental flow” to keep it healthy. 

    The SRT prepared a detailed strategy to fix the issue in 2015, tasking several state departments to take action, but the most recent progress report from August 2020 reveals several unfinished items. 

    Delayed or “at risk” items include managing “environmental flows” (a lack of flow let the 2012 algae sit around for months), monitoring contaminants, and research to investigate threats to the river’s ecosystem.

    For now the potential spread of the fish kill is being monitored and anyone who sees dead or sluggish fish in other areas of the river are asked to call FishWatch on 1800 815 507.

  • History buffs say Hyde kiosk a risk
    Australian Garden History Society (WA) branch chair John Viska. File photo by David Bell.

    PLANS to put a commercial kiosk in Hyde Park has the WA branch of the Australian Garden History Society “deeply concerned”.

    The society says the kiosk could be detrimental to the park’s health and heritage, and it should be retained as a non-commercial space.  

    Vincent council is testing public opinion on whether to put a permanent kitchen kiosk in the same building as the toilets near the western playground. It’s up for debate as to whether it’d replace food trucks, or operate along along with them.

    AGHS(WA) branch chair John Viska knows the park and its history like few others, having co-authored the 2003 Hyde Park Conservation Plan commissioned by Vincent council. 

    Threat

    In a letter to council last week, he said the society’s concerns had been picked up by its national branch, and “as a consequence [Hyde Park] has been placed on the AGHS’s ‘Landscapes at Risk’ list.

    The list includes significant gardens and cultural landscapes facing a threat from development or neglect.

    Mr Viska’s letter says the park will be impacted by “building activity, parking, signage, rubbish generation, [and] disposal” from the kiosk. 

    While the council wants to “activate” the park, the conservation plan warns some sensitive trees needed less activity in order to survive.

    Mr Viska wrote in his letter that the kiosk “is in close proximity to a 120-year-old  Moreton Bay Fig… increased activation in this area will have a deleterious effect on the health of the tree”.

    Mayor Emma Cole said in a statement about the kiosk: “It’s time to have a conversation about how we want to enjoy Hyde Park into the future and what food and drink options we want on offer at the park, if at all.

    “For many people – from those who are enjoying a picnic to parents watching their children playing in the water playground – food and coffee are a big part of the park experience.

    “Hyde Park has a reputation as one of Perth’s most beautiful parks and we want to make sure it keeps bringing back visitors and locals alike.”

    Public comment’s open til April 2 at imagine.vincent.wa.gov. au and a decision’s due at the April 27 council meeting.

  • Park named after pioneer councillor
    Ms Tant’s descendants Lorraine Reithmuller, Margaret Douglas and Ian Douglas, meet Bayswater mayor Dan Bull at the park, just across from the Essex Street Reserve.

    THE first woman elected to a WA road board, Nellie Fawdrey Tant, has had a park named in her honour.

    Bayswater mayor Dan Bull first moved to name a park after Ms Tant back in 2019. She was elected to Bayswater’s predecessor the Belmont-Bayswater Road Board in 1921. The first woman to be on a road board and the second to be on a council, she was a key figure in the Women’s Service Guilds of WA which campaigned to win women the right to nominate. 

    The Strand Reserve was chosen as a potential green monument to Ms Tant and following a lengthy process “Nellie Tant Reserve” was officially proclaimed on March 8, International Women’s Day. 

    Cr Bull says: “The commemorative naming of the reserve is a wonderful way to celebrate such an important milestone for women in WA history.

    “We consulted the community on the naming and liaised with both Ms Tant’s family and the Bayswater Historical Society to gather information and ensure it was an appropriate way of honouring Ms Tant’s significant political achievement.”

    Landgate policy usually opposes naming places after a person for their public service, but given Ms Tant’s pioneering contribution gave it the green light.

    Nellie Fawdrey Tant

    Courtesy the Bayswater Historical Society

    Nellie Tant was born Helen Fawdrey Hatton in 

    England, 1880.

    As a young woman she worked as a seamstress, and later married Richard Tant, a painter and decorator.

    They had three surviving children, all daughters: Florence Edith May, Nellie Alberta Kathleen, and Doris Lorna Kathleen.

    In 1913 the family, who were living in Richmond (now Kew Gardens), Surrey, England, immigrated to Australia, landing at Fremantle on the SS Armadale in that year.

    The family eventually settled in Traylen Road, Bayswater. 

    Nellie Tant had many interests; the suffragette movement in England, the Spiritualist Church in Maylands, the St John Ambulance Brigade, the Women’s Service Guild, and was a feminist with strong political convictions in the area of women’s interests.

    Nellie Tant had an enquiring turn of mind and innovations in any field were of great interest to her.

    Ms Tant’s political and community interests took her into local government, when on April 9, 1921 she was elected to the West Ward of Bayswater Road Board.

  • Anzac Cottage marches along to women’s history month

    A World War II era Women’s Land Army Recruitment poster.

    ANZAC Cottage is marking Women’s History Month with its March Anzac Afternoon dedicated to the Australian Women’s Land Army.

    The AWLA was formed after Japan entered World War II, with Australian prime minister John Curtin’s response to the threat to build-up the armed forces, leaving labour shortfalls at home.

    Women were recruited to work the emptied farms and keep the nation fed. 

    They were often from cities and unskilled in rural work, prompting skepticism as to whether they’d be up to the task. But soon “skeptical attitudes … generally changed to praise and respect,” according to the Australian War Memorial.

    By December 1943 there were 2300 full timers doing at least 12 months’ service, and 1000 auxiliary members working for a few weeks at a time. 

    They grew vegetables and fruit, raised pigs and poultry for food, and sheep for wool, but were still paid far less than men working the same jobs.

    Cabinet endorsed a plan from labour and national service minister Eddie Ward to improve their conditions in 1943, but the legislation wasn’t completed until the war was over, and the farm workers missed out on the benefits given to other women’s services. 

    In 1997 ALWA members were made eligible for the Civilian Service Medal. 

    The Anzac Cottage event is on Sunday March 28 from 1.30-4pm at 38 Kalgoorlie Street, Mount Hawthorn. There’s a talk on the skills and work of the Land Army women at 2.30pm. It’s free, and a gold coin donation covers afternoon tea.

  • FOGO caddies out in a month

    FOGO is starting in Bayswater with the “kitchen caddies” going out now and due to be in every home within the next four weeks.

    Under the new three bin system the lime green lidded bins currently used for garden waste will now also take food and be picked up weekly. The kitchen caddies are little bins with compostable liners for food waste, because plastic bags can’t go in the green bin. 

    The red-lidded bins will be for non-organic waste that can’t go in the recycling bin, and they’ll now be picked up fortnightly. 

    Nappies have been a big sticking point because they’ll now be sitting for up to 14 days in the red bin instead of being collected weekly. 

    Bayswater’s put out a lengthy list of tips for reducing odour from nappies, continence pads and menstrual products. Residents are advised to try tipping the contents into the toilet before disposing, double-sealing them in plastic bags before they go in the red bin, putting kitty litter in the bin to neutralise odours, and keeping the bin out of direct sunlight.

    Bayswater council predicts about half of what currently goes in the general bin will be instead be kept out of landfill and turned to compost. 

    The state government wants all councils to shift to FOGO but Bayswater’s done it early for environmental reasons but also reckons it “makes financial sense” according to the letter going out to residents this week.

    “We will avoid paying the state government waste levy on food and organic waste sent to landfill”.

    Businesses can opt out but only by switching to a commercial waste collector. 

    by DAVID BELL

  • Locals meet over WACA plans

    EAST PERTH residents will meet with WA Cricket Association representatives this week to get a better idea of the planned WACA redevelopment.

    A reno of the WACA’s been on the drawing board for years since Perth’s new stadium was announced in 2011, and given more impetus in 2013 when the WACA was overlooked to host an international test match for the first time since the 1970s.

    The East Perth Community Group’s facilitating the WACA meet because there’s been many various plans over the years, and it wants “to learn what exactly is going to be in our backyard”. They’ll be hearing about it directly from WACA CEO Christina Matthews. 

    The latest plan will see the WACA downsized as a 10,000 capacity “boutique venue” and include more areas open to the public.

    Pool

    The state and federal governments have already committed money to the project but it’d still need cash from the landowner, Perth council. The council’s worried by the addition of a 50-metre pool, as it would have to pay the yearly maintenance bill.

    Labor’s state MP for Perth John Carey says there’s been a lot of local interest, and “I think there is some confusion out there and I understand part of the difficulty is there’s not been a final agreement between the City [of Perth] and WACA regarding the design.

    “This forum will provide an opportunity for the WACA to directly brief the community and also for the community to ask questions.

    “It will also break down some of the myths out there and also address some of the issues.

    “For example, the council claims there’ll be a $1.4 million loss per year, which neither the WACA or the state government accepts.”

    It’s on March 17 at 6pm at the WACA, tickets are via eventbrite (just search “East Perth Community Group WACA Redevelopment Update”), but interest is high and it is booking out fast.

    by DAVID BELL