• Speakers Corner: Grey area
    Andrea Pollard with state parliament’s own Dr Doolittle and Maylands MP Lisa Baker.

    MOST sports around the country are shut down, but greyhounds in WA are still running every day without a live audience in race meets closed to the public. In this week’s Speaker’s Corner, Coalition for the Protection of Greyhounds’ WA divisional manager Andrea Pollard reminds us these animals are still being badly injured.

    IN a time when greyhound racing tracks are closing all over the world, the WA greyhound racing industry recently began seven-day racing. 

    With the cruelty implicit within the industry now widely known, it’s a backward step which is bad for WA’s image.

    WA started seven-day racing last month, with the launch being marked by three-year old greyhound Titanium Bolt suffering a right hind leg tarsal fracture at Mandurah.

    Titanium Bolt was injured after a collision, so won’t race for 90 days like three other dogs hurt during a five day horror stretch in late March, with a fifth dog stood down for 42 days.

    While the government claims WA has the safest animal welfare-wise industry in the world, 

    these unfortunate dogs are now being injured seven days a week for no other reason but human entertainment and making money.

    Sunday race meetings are alternating between Mandurah and Cannington, so we’ll see more injuries at both tracks. 

    Neither place has used racing industry-funded research to make it safer for the dogs.

    Meanwhile, research done by University of Technology Sydney in 2017 recommended straight tracks and six-dog races, instead of the usual eight to reduce injuries and deaths, yet nothing has changed.

    With no action taken on this in WA, 21 greyhounds have suffered horrific leg fractures on the state’s racing tracks this year as of 31 March 2020. 

    Racing supporters like to say such injuries are inevitable in sport, just as in football. That makes no sense. 

    We don’t kill footballers when they break an ankle, yet that’s what they do to greyhounds.

    Also, these dogs don’t choose to be professional athletes or get to bank their winnings. 

    Unnecessary deaths and injuries are inevitable in greyhound racing. 

    Anyone who’s come across one of these beautiful dogs will understand their kind gentle nature. 

    Greyhounds should be lying on couches, not running for their lives. 

  • Getting square  
    • Wandandi artist Sandra Hill’s concept for the Wellington Square Stolen Generations reflective artwork.

    NOONGAR artist Sandra Hill has been selected to create a new Wellington Square artwork acknowledging the Stolen Generations.

    Part of the square upgrades, the work will replace the Sorry Pole which was unveiled by the Bringing Them Home Committee in 2006 for the Sorry Day held there each May 26.

    The Bringing Them Home Committee was brought in to consult on the replacement, and along with Stolen Generations advocacy group Yokai they’ve been interviewing survivors and their families about what they’d like to see there.

    Jim Morrison (from both Yokai and BTHC) says it’s an important spot for the Whadjuk Noongar who’d lived there for thousands of years when it was a wetland, and it’s “considered a safe meeting place, with many spiritual links and memories”.

    Perth city council received tenders from three artists, and with input from elders Perth commissioners chose the Sandra Hill work.

    Hill is a member of the Stolen Generations and says she knows first hand the “grief, loss and heartbreak from having had that experience”.

    She said in a statement: “I also understand what it’s like to survive that experience and the things that you hold forever in your heart. I understand what needs to be said through art.”

    Hill was born in Perth in 1951. At seven years old she was taken from her parents and placed in Sister Kate’s Orphanage, then at nine she was fostered by a white family. 

    After 27 years she was reunited with her mum, a Ballardong and Wilmen Nyoongar, and her dad, who was a Wadandi and Minang Noongar. 

    Her art is based on “mias”, or homes, and incomplete mias representing regions of WA around a Whadjuk Noongar centrepiece of red-tailed black cockatoo feathers.

    The incomplete mias will be made whole by bushes growing around and through their latticing, representing restoration. 

    The $483,800 artwork will be funded through the council’s Public Art Reserve, made up of developer “Per Cent for Art” contributions and the council’s own yearly deposit.

    It’s scheduled to be finished and installed March 2021. 

  • Calm retreat

    THE wisteria-covered balcony of this Mt Lawley home overlooks the suburb’s leafy streets, offering quiet contemplation in these fraught times.

    Come spring the magnificent cluster of delicate mauve flowers will hopefully welcome in a pandemic-free world.

    Meanwhile, lockdown in this gorgeous federation mansion will seem like a resort holiday, with numerous white shutters creating the feel of a swish beach house.

    This 837sqm lot has a delightful Victorian-style pavilion in the lush front garden, where you can enjoy a glass of wine and commune with the neighbours – some 150 metres away.

    Built in the early 1900s, heritage details like art nouveau fireplaces, ceiling roses, stained glass and jarrah floors abound.

    This four-bedroom/three-bathroom home is so large, social distancing would be a breeze.

    When you’re bored of online movies, head to the central library and curl up with a good book in a window seat the size of a double bed.

    The light’s perfect for reading here, with floor-to-ceiling windows on two sides.

    If you’re working from home there’s a spacious office across the hall with built-in desks and cupboards, and all the latest tech for video conferencing.

    You’ll soon stop ordering takeaway because the huge kitchen is every chef’s dream.

    It’s dominated by a massive Falcon Elan stove – a black beast with six gas burners, two conventional ovens and a warming oven.

    There’s a sweep of marble benchtops, a huge breakfast bar, loads of cupboards and drawers, and a walk-in pantry.

    A wall of glass in the huge family area leads to a terracotta-tiled alfresco with a bar and wood-fired pizza oven. High walls and greenery ensure the pool is safe from prying eyes.

    This is a great home for multi-generational living with a separate bedroom/bathroom suite for older parents, or young adults still living at home.

    By JENNY D’ANGER

  • Some thing in the air
    This is a safe distance. Drone footage of the April 12 event by Jack Higgins.
    Activate Perth CEO Kylie Taylor with Ralph the dog, muso Chris Murphy, and AP Chair Di Bain, keeping a quarantine distance.

    LIVE music returned to the city this week as residents in East and West Perth emerged from their balconies to musicians playing for the neighbourhood.

    Activate Perth’s City Sessions socially-distanced show on April 12 brought 15 artists to balconies, tennis courts and rooftops to liven up quarantine life for people in apartments.

    The idea came about after East Perth Community Group chair Anne-Maree Ferguson was inspired by scenes of residents in northern Italy keeping up morale by singing to each other from their balconies.

    The EPCG ran the first session on March 22 in East Perth, and after a warm response Activate Perth put in funding for an expanded April 12 show, bringing in the West Perth Local community group for that wing. 

    Activate Perth chair Di Bain says “it was amazing… we were overwhelmed with the number of responses from people just saying how nice it was”.

    They had to get the event cleared with Perth council and police, but crowd control was pretty easy with everyone used to keeping apart. 

    “We had to submit a risk assessment, we had to make sure everyone was social distancing, so I went down as crowd control and I took my little dog. I got messages from people saying it was so nice to see your little dog blissfully unaware of everything!”

    Ms Bain says there’s more to come: “We’re working up to another couple of sessions, one for Mother’s Day and one for WA Day”.

    by DAVID BELL

    ADVERT
  • Planning zone grows

    Bayswater council is fine with a slightly expanded WA government control zone, as long as the state takes care of the parks.

    THE Bayswater train station upgrade rolls along with the WA government selecting a tenderer to design and build the station, platform and surrounds.

    The tenderer is Evolve Bayswater Alliance, a project name of Coleman Rail, subsidiary of the Spanish-based infrastructure giant Acciona. 

    This $253 million stage will link the Midland line to Metronet’s Forrestfield-airport link and the Morley-Ellenbrook Line.

    Coleman has previously handled local projects including the Ashton Street Bridge, Hamilton Street Bridge, and the two new bridges on Albany Highway.

    Transport minister Rita Saffioti announced the selection saying “building this project, combined with construction of other nearby major projects like the Tonkin Gap and Morley-Ellenbrook Line, will help support the WA economy through some tough times ahead.

    “In times like these it’s important we continue to progress the projects that will provide work for local businesses and keep workers in their jobs. This will ultimately support the state’s wider economy.”

    The WA government has taken over interim planning control of the station’s surrounds off Bayswater council, in order to bring in larger developments and a bigger population to make use of the train station upgrades.

    Currently the WAPC handles applications in the area. 

    The official boundaries of the full takeover area were announced March 20 and cover a larger patch than first announced, creeping northwards to include two large parks: Mills Avenue Park and Halliday Park.

    Bayswater council itself had requested the expansion back in June 2019, with a council agenda stating the parks will need to be “protected” and “enhanced… to meet the needs of the growing population”.

    If the parks were left outside the state’s control area then any of the protecting and enhancing would be done on council dime.

    The newly announced boundaries and the complete takeover come into effect late 2020, and then decisions will be made by Labor’s planning supergroup DevelopmentWA. 

    by DAVID BELL

    ADVERT
    ADVERT
  • Park sale scuttled

    TWO Leederville parks owned by Vincent council will not be sold off, following a unanimous vote by councillors.

    Council staff recommended selling off five lots to help finance Covid-19 relief efforts and soften the blow to city coffers (“Land sale for Covid-19 relief,” Voice, April 4, 2020). 

    At the April 7 meeting councillors pulled the two chunks of public open space at lots 74 and 100 Brentham Street off the table entirely. 

    They’ll still move ahead with selling two smaller lots, both awkward nubs of land that are probably only useful to the immediate neighbour (150 Charles Street and 202 Vincent Street). 

    The council’s newly-formed Covid-19 Relief and Recovery Committee will set a minimum price after a real estate agent values the lots, and the money will be quarantined in a reserve until the next budget. 

    Mayor Emma Cole, who’d flagged ahead of the meeting she wasn’t keen on selling off public open space, said it was worth looking at the council’s landholdings to see if they were being well utilised, but added “it’s a difficult time for councillors to be making decisions around large tracts of land when we’re just starting into a crisis”.

    She said reviewing the city’s properties needs to be done “in a way where we bring the community along with us and explain why… and give an opportunity for the community to engage in that”. 

    The council will now consult on potentially selling a block at 26 Brentham Street, the music house they got in a recent land swap deal with Aranmore Primary School.

    The portion of the Barlee Street Carpark that the city owns has also been moved from the “sell now” list to the “ask the public” list, as has the narrow block at 10 Monmouth Street. 

    What ratepayers say

    Highgate’s Peter Le: “Why is the city selling public open spaces, when the city goes to great lengths to close residents’ streets to create open spaces? I ask councillors to reject or defer the decision in order to get a better understanding of the city’s financial future before making any rash decisions.”

    Mt Hawthorn’s Norelle O’Neill: “You have all been granted the privilege of being the custodians, not owners, of the city’s much loved open spaces, so you can protect and nurture them for future generations. Open spaces belong to the community for healing, not profiteering developers.

    ADVERT
  • Plea to help artists

    LABOR’S federal Perth MP Patrick Gorman has penned a notice of motion imploring the Morrison government to rescue artists slipping through the Covid-19 welfare cracks.

    The motion calls the arts sector “an essential part of our economy, our community and our identity”.

    It says the Covid-19 coronavirus has “destroyed the livelihoods of thousands of working artists” including writers, designers, illustrators, musicians, fine artists, filmmakers and children’s entertainers.

    The JobKeeper payments don’t apply to a lot of the artists working gig-to-gig, and Mr Gorman’s called for a “tailored package of support to the arts sector”.

    arts with almost every event cancelled, and a lot of the backup seasonal gigs artists do on the side like bar or restaurant jobs also drying up. 

    The Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance estimates “tens of thousands of freelance and casual performers and crew” are denied Jobkeeper. 

    Many are freelance performers and crew hired for short-term contracts for one show or season, and casuals can only get Jobkeeper if they’ve been with the same employer for 12 months.

    The notice of motion, seconded by federal Fremantle MP Josh Wilson, is scheduled to be moved on the next sitting date in August but Mr Gorman wants the federal treasurer Josh Frydenberg to act sooner. 

    Mr Gorman says the August date is “disappointing” and Labor is pushing for an earlier reconvening: “If we sit in April or May I will seek to have this motion listed for debate that week.

    “In the meantime, the motion is one way of putting pressure on the government to change their position.

    “Under the laws, treasurer Josh Frydenberg has the power to extend the program to those who currently miss out.

    “The only thing standing between the arts community and support through the JobKeeper program is the treasurer’s signature.”

    The discretion was built into the bill to let the treasurer act without having to recall parliament. 

    Labor and the Greens have both been urging the treasurer to extend the package to other groups left out, like temporary visa-holders and casual employees who weren’t at their current job for at least 12 months. 

    by DAVID BELL

    ADVERT
  • Park honour for suffragette

    THE first woman elected to a WA road board is set to be honoured with Bayswater council naming Nellie Tant Reserve after her.

    Nellie Fawdrey Tant (1880 to 1949) was elected to the Belmont-Bayswater Road Board on April 9, 1921, before resigning the next year. 

    The park, informally named The Strand Reserve, is the patch of green across from Essex Street Reserve.

    Bayswater council wrote to 608 landowners and residents nearby, and got 10 submissions, eight of them supportive. 

    Councillors will vote on whether to support the naming on April 21, and the WA government’s Landgate gets to make the final decision.

    Landgate policy opposes naming places after someone for their public service, but a Bayswater council report says they hope she’ll be “considered  exception due to her outstanding achievement” in being the first woman elected to a road board. 

    Despite only having a short stint on the Belmont-Bayswater Road Board in 1921-1922, Nellie Fawdrey Tant was already active in the background of WA’s suffragette movement. 

    A member of the Maylands Spiritualist Church, she was a key player in the Women’s Service Guilds of WA, which helped get the first woman elected to local government in 1920 when Elizabeth Chapman becoming a Cottesloe Councillor. 

    The WSG lobbied successfully to have the Municipal Corporations Act amended in 1919 as it disqualified women from running for councils.

    It also pushed for the introduction of the Qualification of Women for Parliament Bill, which paved the way for Edith Cowan to become Australia’s first female MP.

    Western Australia was noted as being pretty progressive on women’s issues at the time: The WSG started west before branching out into other states.

    The news of Mrs Tant’s election made the “Tea-Table Gossip” section of the NSW Sunday Times. It announced her win with a small article stating: “West Australia still goes ahead as the state with the progressive women”; the article sandwiched below society gossip and just above a recipe for steak and kidney pudding.

    England-born, Nellie Tant had three children (including another Nellie who became night superintendent at RPH) and died December 26 1949 “in her 70th year”. 

    by DAVID BELL

    ADVERT
  • A bad decision underlined by planning flaws

    Former Bayswater councillor Chris Cornish still keeps an eye on local government, and was taken aback by City of Perth commissioners’ support for Brookfield’s over-sized Elizabeth Quay towers as “a political response” to the impact of Covid-19 on WA’s economy. In this week’s Speaker’s Corner he dissects three failings of a flimsy planning system. 

    LAST week’s Perth Voice article, “Corona Towers” (April 11, 2020) highlights a number of failings with WA’s planning legislation and implementation. 

    The first is the explanation provided from the state government-appointed chair commissioner at the City of Perth, Andrew Hammond, for his support of the two new Elizabeth Quay towers. 

    Specifically that it is a “political response to the Covid crisis”, which begs the question as to whether any state politician, or their representative, has approached the commissioner and lobbied on behalf of the developer.

    Regardless of the answer though, Covid-19 is not a proper planning consideration on which to support this development, and should not be used to override the expert officer’s views.

    The second is the feeble protections that currently exist in ensuring that appropriate developments occur.

    The Elizabeth Quay Design Guidelines allow for variations to building heights where “innovation and exemplary design quality can be demonstrated to have a positive impact on the project area and the city skyline as a whole”. 

    Yet the City of Perth officer’s report to the commissioners states that the development “will impact on the amenity and enjoyment of this important public space within Elizabeth Quay” and “the numerous variations sought by the applicant should not be supported until the architectural and civic outcomes of the design are of sufficient quality that they meet the criteria for design excellence”. 

    Despite this, a building almost double what was envisaged for the area has been unanimously recommended for approval by Commrs Andrew Hammond, Gaye McMath and Len Kosova.

    The third failing is how easily the planning system can be gamed.

    An alternate, more expensive, 56-storey design from the developer was granted in-principal support in 2017.

    The officer’s at the time wrote: “[It] has the potential to create a landmark development for the city. The development will also contribute to the precinct in terms of providing significant areas of public space…”. 

    When questioned in the recent council meeting for the reasons for why the developer was seeking an allowance for extra height on the latest proposal, the City of Perth planning officer responded that there were “no clear reasons stated beyond initial in-principal approval which had a similar height building”.

    So, submit an awesome design and get support, then a couple of years later, submit a lesser design and get approval with a similar height based upon getting the initial approval. 

    Illogical to most people that this can work, but there you have it.  It does and I have observed this strategy in action numerous times.

    In this particular instance, the City of Perth are merely providing a recommendation to DevelopmentWA who will be the ultimate decision makers. 

    However one would hope there is weight placed on the city’s recommendation otherwise it is just red tape and the requirement for it to go via a local government authority should be removed. 

    I personally don’t care either way, I just want to see a consistent approach where everyone operates on a level playing field. 

    Sadly, this is not the case and too many planning decisions are based on ad-hoc, subjective and spurious rationales.

    ADVERT
  • Nothing but honest to goodness tucker 
    Fibber McGee’s restaurant manager Aaron Browne. Photo by David Bell.

    WINTER was supposed to be a good season for Fibber McGee’s.

    The Leederville Irish pub’s hearty food and dark stouts usually sees trade pick up in the colder months, a reversal of the patterns at a lot of summery bars.

    But in the space of a week they went from celebrating St Patrick’s Day on March 17 to having their dining area shut down along with all other restaurants and bars by federal government decree on March 23. 

    On that Monday, restaurant manager Aaron Browne gathered with the few other staff remaining to work out what to do.

    “It was a drastic week,” Mr Browne says, with trade slowing in the days leading up to the official shutdown. “It was getting harder. A lot of things were happening around the world. 

    “I had 20 staff before and now there’s just three of us.” 

    But they had an adaptation advantage over many pubs which were focussed just on alcohol sales: Fibber was opened up by publican John Little in 1998 and was far ahead of the gastropub trend, and had built a reputation on high end cuisine. Behind the cosy bar is an immaculate dining room, and from pre-shutdown visits the Voice can confirm the fare is top notch. 

    They adapted fast, becoming part grocery store, part takeaway restaurant. 

    “Luckily we had a bottleshop licence before,” Mr Browne says, so they can keep selling the stock of alcohol. “We’ve been here 21 years, we’ve got a good name, people know us and they know we sell good quality food.”

    The extra produce that’d normally go into the kitchen is now on sale as groceries for anyone who’s not keen on braving a supermarket: Irish soda bread, fruit and veg, and their dry aged steaks they hang for a minimum of 31 days. 

    The kitchen’s still running and they’ve adapted some of the restaurant menu for takeaway too. 

    Like many independent restaurants, the ~30 per cent of the overall price UberEats takes just for delivery is too much to take right now, so they’re sticking to takeaway only, sold right from the open shop front without anyone having to enter.

    There’s no end date set for the dining restriction. If this goes on for three months, it’ll be a tough ride, Mr Browne says.

    “It is working. We are making some money. Not a lot of money… but there’s no other option.

    “It’s either do this, try to earn some money, or stay at home on the couch.”

    Hospitality staff have borne the brunt of the shutdown measures. Many like Mr Browne are from overseas and aren’t eligible for the jobkeeper program. He’s sponsored by the business and can’t work elsewhere.

    But he didn’t want to head back to Ireland: Flights back were exorbitant as coronavirus bloomed mid-March, hitting $12,000. And after six years here he’s keen on sticking this out in Australia. If he flew back and Fibber’s was to reopen in a few months, the borders might stay closed long term.

    The customers over the past few weeks have been a mix of familiar faces and newcomers wanting to support the business. 

    “We’re getting a lot of support from the Irish community,” he says. “And we get new customers. We’ve got customers coming in the past couple of weeks we didn’t know before. 

    Fibber McGee’s
    711 Newcastle St, Leederville
    Noon to 8pm every day except Tuesday
    Order: fibbermcgees.com.au
    Daily specials at facebook.com/FibberMcGeesPerth
    0459 922 008

    ADVERT